This quest is gained from the item ""The Phylactery of Kel'Thuzad"". The item is a 100% drop off Kel'Thuzad and starts a quest for two items that increase damage done to undead/demons.

Personally, I think the trinket isn't that great for melee or casters, though it is better than quite a few trinkets while in Naxx. In my oppinion, as the others have said, it'll be great for the expansion due the large expectancy for demon mobs in Outland.

While the trinket reward might not be the greatest, the best reward comes first.

The quest text.

This is easily my favorite quest text in the entire game.

""Who cares if Kel'Thuzad regenerates to full power?""

I won't pretend like I know anything about fighting Archimonde and Illidan as anything besides at 70 warlock, but I know that I'd love to have this trinket until I finally get a skull of gul'dan. Why? Because there aren't ""hundreds of trinkets at that level exponentially greater"" than it (assuming you're fighting undead/demons). In fact, there are only 2 trinkets better than it. Hex Shrunken Head and Skull of Gul'dan.

Unless you're fighting something other than a demon or undead, this is the 3rd best trinket in the game for a warlock.

http://wiki.shadowpriest.com/index.php?title=SimulationCraft/Trinkets/Warlock http://wiki.shadowpriest.com/index.php?title=SimulationCraft/Trinkets/Warlock
note: Eye of Magtheridon only breaks the +85 damage mark when you have 12% hit (which no BT/Hyjal raider should have) so it doesn't really count in this scenario.

Please don't ""shoot"" anyone who thinks this trinket is good.

Aaaaaand he's back in Wrath. Good job, classic raiders, you screwed us all over =/

Unless you had the https://vanillawowdb.com/?item=22520 The Phylactery of Kel'Thuzad still in your inventory at the time https://vanillawowdb.com/?zone=3456 Naxxramas got relocated to https://vanillawowdb.com/?zone=65 Dragonblight, Northrend, it is no longer possible to obtain this quest or it's rewards, as the item that starts this quest has been removed in the new Wrath of the Lich King Naxxramas.

Well...my voice of inner reason was right, and he did regenerate to full power....BUT we did get a title in the long run!